Rent vs Buy — Advance calculator
Same owner-occupier model as the article: equal starting cash, growing repairs, sale friction, and an investing renter. Change any number. The tables and charts follow. Defaults reproduce the published base case (−RM238k at 0.6% growth / 5.5% opportunity cost).
Your numbers
Article defaults are pre-filled. Open a group to edit.
Property & rent
Loan
Owning costs
Growth, CPI vs opportunity cost
Wealth if the home is sold
Buyer = property value − remaining loan − selling cost. Renter = initial cash + invested monthly gaps, compounded at r.
Annual cash out
Ownership cash = instalment + strata + assessment + quit rent + insurance + repairs. Rent inflates with CPI. The gap is what the renter invests.
Year-by-year ledger
Same columns as the article. Intermediate “buyer net worth if sold” uses the full 2.5% selling cost every year so the path is consistent.
Sensitivity heatmap — Buy − Rent at terminal year (RM ’000)
Rows are price growth. Columns are the renter’s opportunity cost. Gold outline is your current (g, r) pair. Green = buying ahead; rust = renting + investing ahead.
How this is calculated
- Both sides start with the same cash: down payment + day-1 costs (minus the first-home exemption if you tick it). The renter invests that stack at r from day one.
- Loan is a standard reducing-balance mortgage. Monthly instalment is derived from price × LTV, rate and tenure — default RM2,148 on RM450,000 at 4% / 30 years.
- Each year the renter invests the annual gap (ownership cash − rent) at year-end. That convention reproduces the published RM576k renter portfolio and −RM238k gap.
- Repairs start at your year-1 figure and compound at repair inflation (default 3%), faster than CPI. Strata, assessment, quit rent, insurance and rent compound at CPI.
- Buyer terminal wealth assumes a sale: value grows at g, minus remaining principal, minus selling cost. RPGT is treated as 0% (citizen/PR from year 6). Do not use this for a year-3 flip.
- A first-home exemption lowers day-1 cash. The saved amount is no longer in the renter’s starting stack, which is why the published gap shrinks from RM238k to RM206k.
Source model: Rent vs Buy KL Condo: 20-Year Math, Not a Sure Win. This page does not give advice. It runs the arithmetic so you can see which assumption actually moves the needle — usually g, r, and whether the renter invests the gap.
Companion calculator for Estate Market Pulse. Owner-occupier comparison only — identical lifestyle, different balance sheet. Numbers are a model, not a prophecy.
Original post: Rent vs Buy KL Condo: 20-Year Math, Not a Sure Win






Leave a Reply